Dating With Dogs: The Blended Multi Dog Household

November 5, 2025
2 dogs, an Australian Shepherd and a Border Collie mix explore large rocks along a shore.

Dating With Dogs: The Blended Multi Dog Household

2 dogs, an Australian Shepherd and a Border Collie mix explore large rocks along a shore.

Dating with dogs is a beautiful thing. You get to bond over your shared love of our canine friends and all of the activities a dog centric lifestyle offers. Adventures in nature. Dog friendly establishments. Dog training and sports. Simple companionship on a quiet winter evening. The joy they have when your new partner comes over. Honestly, I love all of that for you!

Over the years I’ve had the pleasure of working with many couples who fell in love with not only each other, but with their partner’s respective dogs as well. Helping these couples create a blended multi dog household is honestly one of my favorite things to do. But what happens when it’s time for the big step of moving in together? How do you make sure your newly blended multi dog household is as happy as you and your partner are? That my friends is what we’re going to talk about today. 

Successfully Dating With Dogs Starts with Bonding with Your Partner’s Dog

The foundations for a successfully blended multi dog household start BEFORE you and your partner are even remotely considering moving in together. If you want a smooth transition one day, then you need to start building your own relationship with your partner’s dog. This is much the same as what you did to build a relationship with your own dog when you brought them home.

But in case you need some tips: 

  1. Ask your partner about their dog’s likes and dislikes before you even meet them. Be ready to do everything in the like category and avoid the dislike category when you meet.
  2. Remember that you know YOUR dog and how you like YOUR dog to be treated and what YOUR dog’s rules are. Every dog is a study of one and every person lives with their dog differently. Be ready to observe, learn and adapt instead of assuming this dog will be like your dog or that your partner will interact in the same way with their dog. 
  3. Be sure and keep consent tests in mind when it comes to touching your partner’s dog and be mindful of any special instructions your partner gives you. 
  4. Help your partner’s dog associate your arrival with good things. Give the dog the level of attention they request, play with them, ask your partner if you can deliver treats, chews, or a meal. 
  5. Draft your partner’s dog into your date activities (as appropriate) for more bonding moments. Go on a walk or hike together, take a car ride, go to a dog friendly establishment, let them join in on your next binge watch on the couch etc.
  6. As your relationship progresses see if you can involve yourself more with your partner’s dog. Can you do a potty break, be the dog sitter when they go out of town, or do a solo walk? 
  7. Do you like training or does your partner? Participate in those activities with your partner’s dog. Make sure the dog is having a good time. Use rewards based methods without corrections or aversives.

Developing an individual relationship with your partner’s dog will make things easier if you have to navigate daily life together later. Remember, there’s a chance this dog could become your dog too one day. Encourage your partner to do the same with your dog.

In this video my client is working with both his dog and his partner’s dog on playing nicely and taking turns outside. It was such a great example of supporting and bonding with your partner’s dog.

These dogs were living together already at the time, but my clients spent a lot of time getting to know each other’s dogs individually before everyone lived together. His dog is the dog you see getting interrupted to go sit on the stump to give space.

 

Explore Your and Your Partner’s Dog Raising Compatibility: 

Raising dogs together has a lot of complications that can be similar to parenting children together. If you own a dog odds are you know that there can be a lot of feelings wrapped up in the way your dog behaves and how you make decisions for them. As your relationship with your partner grows you may find that you have different opinions about all sorts of things about dogs. From rules and boundaries like are they allowed on the bed to things like spending or the methodology behind how you train or deal with misbehavior. Can you come together on those things? Agree to disagree and stay in your own lane with your own dogs?   

Here are some things you might want to know when you’re dating with dogs: 

  1. Does your partner give their dog regular veterinary care and preventative care? Do they take their dog to the vet when they’re sick or in pain?
    1. These things can impact your dog if they ultimately end up spending a lot of time or living together.
  2. What does your partner do when their dog does something right? What about when their dog does something wrong? Do you have similar views on navigating life with dogs?
    1. If you have been a part of the dog world long enough, you know how emotionally charged these differences can be, they can even be dealbreakers in relationships sometimes.
  3. Do you have similar financial views on budgeting for dog’s needs? 
    1. Finances come into any relationship eventually. Similar spending levels, or just no pushback if you’re spending more can be most compatible. But like anything, you can work together to find something you’re both comfortable with.
  4. Does your partner’s level of care for their dog’s coat, nails, and other basics leave you feeling comfortable, concerned, something in between?
    1. Not everyone does everything the same way and some dogs present limitations based on behavior or medical conditions. People have their own limitations here too based on their own physical abilities and financial constraints.
  5. Do you share or can you compromise on rules and boundaries for your dogs?
    1. This is a big flash point for people and depending on the answers and your individual flexibility, it’s even incompatible sometimes.
  6. Is your partner taking any behavioral issues with their dog seriously? Are there potential safety issues for you or for the general public?
    1. Not taking care of behavioral issues and being loose with public safety with an iffy dog is worrisome. One because, your dog may need to integrate with this dog one day. Second, because liability is a major issue with unsafe dogs in public spaces.
  7. Are you both feeling good about the interactions each of you are having with the other’s dog? Are you able to communicate and come to an agreement about things that aren’t working?
    1. If you can’t communicate now, living together might not be the best idea.

Prepare both dogs for a possible life together (or at least YOUR dog):

You may not know if this relationship is going to go the distance yet. But you can do things that will help make things go easier if it does. Trust me you do not want to realize you need to do these things at the last minute and delay your move in date. Plus even if this relationship doesn’t work out in the end, this will help you and your dog live a happier life together or with your next partner with a dog.

  1. Learn about meeting dog’s needs. This will help your dog put their best paw forward in a new dog relationship later.
  2. Do a thorough veterinary screening to make sure your dog is healthy and not in pain. Unaddressed medical issues and pain are a huge driver of conflict between dogs.
  3. Address individual behavioral issues with a professional dog trainer. This gets so much harder with two dogs who may learn bad things from each other.
  4. Teach skills that will make multi dog living easier. From the basics like sit, down, stay, loose leash walking to behaviors that help dogs disengage like a positive interrupter, hand target, or recall. 
  5. Start gaining skills for reading and understanding dog body language so that you can make confident decisions when the dogs interact later.

Let the dogs meet each other before they have to live together.

The WORST outcome in dating with dogs is moving in together only to have the dogs reveal that they absolutely HATE each other. Then you have dog fights on your hands and things get really stressful and really hard, really quickly. I know because I help couples with this ALL THE TIME. Preferably, you go into this move in decision knowing whether or not you’re about to decide to live on dog Alcatraz and have to invest in a dog behavior professional just to make things liveable. 

Once you’re both feeling comfortable with each other’s dogs individually it’s time to CONSIDER introducing the dogs to each other in a neutral environment. I say consider because not all dogs are great candidates for what’s considered the best way to introduce dogs. Check out my graphic series on parallel walks for more information. 

Moving in Together: Successfully Blending Dog Households

two brown and white dogs look at the camera while in a down position with their backs touching.

While I can’t give you the whole picture in one blog post, I can get you started. For more information check out my other resources like 10 Big Dog Introduction Mistakes

  1. Discuss and create new routines and schedules for the dogs in their new home. Transition the dogs to these routines and schedules before they have to move in together. Eating, sleeping, and home alone routines are often the biggest changes.
  2. Practice living with dog/baby gates and separating from your dog within your home. There are going to moments and periods where you do not want both dogs together in those early days. Make sure both dogs are ready to be alone. 
  3. Stock up on what I lovingly call “Shut Up!!” Stuff for multi dog households. Chews. Rubber toys that can be  stuffed with food and frozen, easy to throw together enrichment activities etc.
  4. SLOW IS FAST. Don’t rush things. Give the dogs their own time and space and have a plan to slowly integrate them over time. Expect a 6 month transition at minimum. 
  5. Work together to create communication systems, cues, and boundaries for the dogs in your home so that everyone is on the same page. 

 

Are you in the middle of Dating with dogs? Need a little help? Check out my multi dog household services, take advantage of my free content, and my free Thriving Multi Dog Households Community Group (coming soon as of the date of this blog post, join now and I’ll accept you when it’s ready). 

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *